The Prologue of James Lowder's Knight
of the Black Rose is a back-story avalanche. Of course, the novel
has to do something to introduce a well-known character like Lord
Soth, but the rapid-fire summation of his career is particularly
clumsy as a narrative technique. Still, there are some elements
worth picking at here. Soth belonged to an order of goody-two-shoes
knights and seems like he was the goodiest-of-two-shoes amongst them.
He marries a noblewoman, builds a keep, quests around fighting evil,
and basically lives a Dudley Do-Right lifestyle. Until he gets it on
with an elf maiden he rescues from some ogres: “Soon after, they
became secret lovers, though in doing so Soth broke both his sacred
marriage vows and the Code of the Knights of Solamnia.” When the
fact of Soth's transgression gets out, he's sentenced to death.
Yeah, you read that correctly, the punishment for having a side piece
in Krynn is death. Infidelity is literally a capital offense. Holy
shitballs, the Dragonlance setting really was created by Mormons!
With the aid of some still-loyal
knights, Soth escapes prison and heads back to his keep where he
attempts to do the right thing. His wife having disappeared, he
marries the elf lady, prepares to raise their child, and prays for
guidance from the gods of good. Yet, for some unexplained reason,
the other elf women that Soth rescued decide to play some mind games
on him: “The elven women he had once rescued now poisoned his mind
with intimations of his wife's infidelity.” Those bitches hate the
playa, not the game. All of this results in Soth letting his wife
and child burn in a fire before his very eyes, his elfbabe honey cursing him with her dying breath, and Soth
emerging as an undead monster.
Already I've got grave concerns about
where this novel is headed. Whereas Vampire of the Mists turned out
to be The Confessions of a Justified Rapist, Knight of the Black Rose
is started out as a whole different kind of psycho-sexual Ravenloft.
Where Golden's novel casually dropped squicky sexual descriptions in
your lap like some unwanted, spittle-sodden dog's chew-toy, Lowder's
ficitive universe so far is one in which sexuality is wrong and must
be punished. Hopefully this aspect of the novel is confined to this
prologue of inherited Dragonlance drivel, but I don't have high hopes
for where this book is about to take me.
...or maybe it will continue the trend
already initiated by Vampire of the Mists. You see, much like Jander
Sunstar, Soth has plans to re-animate Kitiara as his eternal
companion that can only be described as “a bit rape-y” and “kind
of necrophiliac-y": “After retreiving her corpse and trapping her
soul, Soth planned to abandon the fight and return to Dargaard Keep.
In the shelter of that hellish place, he could perform a rite that
would make the highlord his un-living companion for all eternity.”
Soth apparently isn't the only undead monstrosity that likes
Kitiara's bodunkadunk; the deathless guardians of the Tower of High
Sorcery seem to have groped her and stripped off her clothes as they
killed her: “Her night-blue dragonscale armor had been stripped
away by the tower's guardians, and her black, tight-fitting doublet
was shredded, revealing her tan beneath.” All the dead guys love
her; what a lucky gal!
Besides having literally unnatural
designs on Kitiara, Soth can't stand thinking about the fact that Tanis
has already tapped that ass; “Tanis had been one of Kitiara's many
lovers,” he thinks as he attempts to duel Tanis to the death. We
also get a view into the nature of Soth's curse, which turns out to
be little more than run-of-the-mill depression: “Yet the death
knight felt no joy at that realization; like many emotions, joy was
denied him by his curse.” Take some Zoloft and get over it, Soth!


I've read this book before. Just take it for what it is: an attempt to shoehorn Lord Soth into Ravenloft.
ReplyDeleteFYI, if you didn't already know, Lowder actually didn't come up with Lord Soth's and Kitiara's backstories. Both can be found in the regular Dragonlance books, specifically the book Dragons of Spring Dawning and the Twins trilogy. So, Lowder has to expand upon material developed by Margaret Weis and Tracy Hickman.
Readers who haven't read those Dragonlance books would need that information to understand why Lord Soth is evil enough to be taken by the Mists.
Have fun reading it! :D
Yeah, I read the Dragonlance books back when I was in junior high and sadly I haven't forgotten the back-stories. And yet, Knight of the Black Rose reiterates Soth's back-story no less than THREE TIMES over the course of the novel. What the what?
DeleteNice review. Gotta say that it hasn't left me tempted to pick up the book but then I generally don't read roleplay game tie-ins as they tend to be a bit, well, meh.
ReplyDelete"Meh" is too kind!
DeleteAlready I've got grave concerns about where this novel is headed.
ReplyDeleteYou and me both, Mr. Shear. You and me both.
Once more into the breach, dear friends, once more.
DeleteWill their ever be a D&D novel worth reading? That's like asking whether a D&D movie worth watching will ever be made...
ReplyDeleteWhich is to say no.
So, you don't have high hopes for the Book of Vile Darkness movie?
DeleteYeah, me neither.
I have purposely blocked the mere thought of that future abomination from my mind. WOTC does not have the best track record when it comes to trying to bring their flagship to the big screen. I honestly accepted The Gamers as THE D&D movie a long time ago and have been happy ever since.
DeleteThat's probably the wisest move, really.
DeleteI read this Waybackthen (picked up for the 3dish cover), and didn't remember a bit of it. Wow.
ReplyDeleteActually, I think poor Kitiara had already been getting a raw deal before this. She is pretty much the only sympathetic figure in the DL trilogy - she has an independent moral compass and all that - and look where it gets her.
Anyone with their own moral compass (especially a woman!) must be crushed by the imposed, idiotic morality of Krynn's gods. That's par for the course in TSR's settings, really.
DeleteOn the brighter side, the products of 90s TSR and their singularly awful code of ethics lead me into the clutches of what is nowadays referred to as "Appendix N", fantasy with roguish heroes and a less syrupy view of moral issues. I cannot say that was a bad thing.
DeleteNot for nothing, I read some Leiber after finishing the Soth novel to get the bad taste out of my mouth.
DeleteThe only things I remember from this book are the phrase "ham-like fists" and Soth punching a red dragon to death.
ReplyDeleteYeah, he basically punches everything in the novel. More on that to come!
DeleteSo Jack I had an honest question regarding Ravenloft in general. What do you personally think of the module that started the whole franchise? I personally like it, with some changes, but I am curious as to what you yourself think of it. Divorced of all the other setting information and revisions made over the years.
ReplyDeleteI6: Ravenloft ROCKS! I actually like quite a few of the 2e AD&D Ravenloft modules as well. Night of the Walking Dead, Feast of Goblyns, Evil Eye, etc. all have nice, steal-able bits.
DeleteMy favorite 2E Ravenloft module has to be Howls in the Night. Nice set up and the "plot" doesn't feel forced. I also like the randomization aspect of the adventure. But yeah I6 is good stuff, like I said I would change a few things but overall its a great module. Glad to hear you like it as well.
DeleteI haven't read Howls in the Night; will have to check that one out!
DeleteIn short the players get lost on the moors in Mordent and end up stumbling on some guy cursed to live forever unless this ghost is put to rest. Its fun because their are four different ways for the story to unfold based on the backgrounds of the two main characters the GM can choose. Ranging from both being black hearted villains to both being good and the whole situation the result of a horrible accident. Pretty cool.
ReplyDeleteAlso since you were interested in the adventure here is the pdf version of it.
ReplyDeletehttps://docs.google.com/file/d/0B2OIiZbQhqCUY2dnY2FhUkF1VEk/edit
Enjoy!