Monday, September 9, 2013

Review: Beyond the Wall and Other Adventures (part 2)


The first part of the review is here.

For folks who want to eschew the playbooks, there are rules for creating a character in the more expected way.  Simply pick a class (Warrior, Rogue, and Mage), roll ability scores (4d6/drop lowest), pick a few skills, etc.  This might be a good "secondary method" for making characters if a replacement or new character is needed in the midst of an ongoing campaign.  Needless to say, characters made this way won't be as flavorful as ones that are made using the playbooks, but what can you do?  Another option is to generate characters with the dwarf, elf, halfling, or noble playbooks as they are not necessarily connected to the starting village.

Oh yes, speaking of the starting village, Beyond the Wall has a quick system for generating that as well.  It's a collaborative system that looks like it would make more than enough starting locations and NPCs of importance to the characters to get things rolling.

Rules-wise, Beyond the Wall is a D&D-derived system with no particular edition allegiance.  For example, it uses:


  • the classic six attributes: Strength, Dexterity, Constitution, Intelligence, Wisdom, and Charisma.  The range for modifiers seems to follow Basic's schema.  The modifiers do much what you would expect: Strength gives you a bonus or penalty to hit and damage with melee weapons, Dexterity gives you a bonus or penalty to ranged attacks and Armor Class, etc.
  • a three-fold Alignment system of Law, Chaos, and Neutrality as in Basic D&D.
  • a Base Attack Bonus that goes up with level, as in 3rd edition.  
  • ascending Armor Class as in 3rd edition.  (Combat is "roll d20+Attack Bonus vs. target's AC.")
  • five Saving Throw categories as in earlier editions of D&D.  (Saving Throws are simple "roll this number or higher on a d20" rolls.)  (There is an option for using 3e's Reflex, Fortitude, and Will saves as well.)
  • characters possess Fortune Points, which function similarly to Action Points in 3rd and 4th editions. Fortune Points can be spent to give a bonus to an ally, re-roll a particularly bad throw of the dice, or to literally cheat death and stabilize a character who has fallen below 0 Hit Points.  While these points may be seen as "plot armor" they do fit the tone and genre that Beyond the Wall is going for.


There are, of course, some differences from baseline D&D assumptions:

There are no weapon restrictions for characters in Beyond the Wall, but there are armor restrictions (this would be the first thing I house ruled...armor restrictions strike me as silly unless they simply modify your abilities).

Skill and ability checks are handled by rolling a d20 lower than the relevant ability score.  So, if you are trying to sneak past the town guard, you might need to roll less than your Dexterity on a d20.  If your character has a particular skill for moving stealthily, they would get a +2 to their Dexterity for the purposes of that roll.  Bonuses and penalties for difficulty are also possible modifiers.

I've seen some people complain that this means that Beyond the Wall doesn't have a unified resolution mechanic, i.e. you aren't always trying to roll high on a d20.  It's true, but I'm okay with this because it gives ability scores an actual purpose in the game other than generating a bonus or penalty to die rolls.  If the lack of a unified resolution mechanic really bothers you, this would be super simple to replace with a 3rd or 4th edition style mechanic.

Beyond the Wall is a class and level system.  Even characters generated using a playbook belong to a character class--it's just that their class selections have been folded into a flavorful lifepath system.  The section on Experience Points is a bit vague, though purposefully so.  As usual, you gain XP for overcoming (not necessarily killing) monsters, but you should also be awarded XP for accomplishing goals, completing adventures, and clever ideas during play.  The text also notes that you should consider "personalizing" advancement (with bonus skills or attribute boosts) if you're playing a long campaign rather than a one-shot adventure.

All in all, the basic system of Beyond the Wall is a nice distillation of D&D's various iterations.  It looks to be simple, elegant, and most importantly, easy to explain to new players.  It definitely achieves the two stated goals for the game: it would be easy for veterans to pick up and play and functions as a solid introduction to RPGs for new players.

Next time: Magic!

12 comments:

  1. The more I hear the more interesting it sounds.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's definitely an impressive rewrite of D&D's system. I've been thinking of how best to do group character generation on G+ actually.

      Delete
  2. Jack. You have articulated the niceties of BtW very well in this article set. Bravo.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like the sound of this game and I was wondering how the character creation would work for characters created past the outset of the campaign (due to deaths, drop-ins and what nots)

    Due the outsider race playbooks offer a unique character creation process?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm afraid that the notion of adding in new characters past the initial group character generation isn't really addressed. I think the easiest method would be to use the more usual "roll for stats and pic warrior, rogue, or mage" would be the best method, though the new character wouldn't be as rooted in the campaign world as much as characters made using a playbook. Then again, they wouldn't be any less situated than the average D&D character, so it's a bit of a wash.

      I've only skimmed the nonhuman playbooks, but I can tell you that the process is the same albeit with very different background bits.

      Delete
  4. I must admit to getting more and more curious about this game all the time. Lloyd Alexander's populist sympathies are certainly a big influence on "The King is Dead," and the Prydian Chronicles inculcated a lifetime love of Welsh legend in me. I'm not really a fan of coming-of-age games, but I might have to give this a try.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Awesome! I think it would be entirely possible to use this for something other than a coming of age story. I could see using the playbooks to make characters and then plunging them into a picaresque adventure far from what they know.

      Delete
  5. By and by, I think the game authors are looking into providing a supplement for what happens truly "Beyond The Wall" - which I hope will include answers to some of the "well now what" questions I've seen posed. When I asked the authors questions regarding how they saw the cooperatively created village fitting into (and most importantly tangibly inter-connecting characters with) the regional area, they mentioned they are actually already working on a supplement along those lines. I don't know if it will be pay-for, or just a supplemental zip.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I emailed them about what was coming out next and got "Village Character Playbooks" i need to print and bind this to really get into it

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I just got a bound copy (with the free supplements) in the mail today. Totally worth it.

      Delete